Act Amending the Penal Code, the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Code of Misdemeanour Procedure (Incitement to Hatred and Hate Crimes) ↗
- Introduced:
- 12 June 2023
- Author:
- Government (Ministry of Justice) · coalition at introduction: Reform, Eesti 200, SDE
- Stage
- Withdrawn
The draft changes how incitement to hatred is punished: public incitement to hatred, violence or discrimination moves from a misdemeanour to a crime. It adds a hate motive as an aggravating circumstance and adds disability as a protected characteristic. According to the explanatory memorandum, the aim is to protect society from the most serious forms while respecting freedom of expression.
Changes and additions
Incitement to hatred becomes a crime
According to the memorandum, public calls to hatred, violence or discrimination were a misdemeanour if they caused danger to a person's life, health or property. The penalty was a fine of up to three hundred fine units or short-term detention.Public incitement is a crime if done in a way that gives reason to fear a following act of violence or a significant threat to public safety. The requirement of a concrete consequence is dropped. The penalty is a pecuniary punishment or up to one year of imprisonment.Aggravated offence
It was a crime if the act caused death, harm to health or another serious consequence, or was committed by a previously punished person. The penalty was up to three years of imprisonment.A heavier penalty (pecuniary punishment or up to three years of imprisonment) applies if the act is committed repeatedly or by a group.Hate motive as an aggravating circumstance
Section 58 of the Penal Code (Karistusseadustik) gains a new aggravating circumstance: committing an offence against a person because of their nationality, race, sex, disability or other listed characteristic.Disability as a protected characteristic
Disability is added to the list of protected characteristics.Adjusting procedural laws
The Misdemeanour Procedure Code (väärteomenetluse seadustik) named the out-of-court body for this misdemeanour and had county courts hear such cases. The Code of Criminal Procedure (kriminaalmenetluse seadustik) referred to section 151 subsections 2 and 4.The misdemeanour-procedure references are removed and § 521 is repealed. The surveillance list refers to the whole of § 151. The law enters into force on 1 November 2023.
How the text changed during the proceedings
- Compared with the introduced text, the latest version only shows the lead committee (the Legal Affairs Committee); the documents show no substantive changes.
Votes
Proposal to reject the bill
Official decision: First reading completed
· · ·
By faction
- Estonia 200Members in total: 14
·
Against · 10- Züleyxa Izmailova
- Juku-Kalle Raid
- Marek Reinaas
- Kalev Stoicescu
- Kadri Tali
- Peeter Tali
- Tarmo Tamm
- Igor Taro
- Tanel Tein
- Hendrik Johannes Terras
Did not vote · 4- Lauri Hussar
- Irja Lutsar
- Liisa-Ly Pakosta
- Toomas Uibo
- Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 14
· ·
In favour · 8- Vadim Belobrovtsev
- Enn Eesmaa
- Andre Hanimägi
- Aleksei Jevgrafov
- Tanel Kiik
- Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
- Jüri Ratas
- Kersti Sarapuu
Did not vote · 4- Jaak Aab
- Andrei Korobeinik
- Lauri Laats
- Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
Absent · 2- Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
- Ester Karuse
- Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 17
·
In favour · 15- Arvo Aller
- Rain Epler
- Ants Frosch
- Kalle Grünthal
- Helle-Moonika Helme
- Mart Helme
- Martin Helme
- Rene Kokk
- Leo Kunnas
- Alar Laneman
- Anti Poolamets
- Evelin Poolamets
- Henn Põlluaas
- Jaak Valge
- Varro Vooglaid
Absent · 2- Kert Kingo
- Siim Pohlak
- Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37
· ·
Against · 34- Annely Akkermann
- Yoko Alender
- Anti Haugas
- Karmen Joller
- Mario Kadastik
- Siim Kallas
- Erkki Keldo
- Liina Kersna
- Meelis Kiili
- Signe Kivi
- Toomas Kivimägi
- Mait Klaassen
- Urmas Kruuse
- Katrin Kuusemäe
- Ants Laaneots
- Hanah Lahe
- Maris Lauri
- Jürgen Ligi
- Eero Merilind
- Marko Mihkelson
- Pärtel-Peeter Pere
- Õnne Pillak
- Valdo Randpere
- Maido Ruusmann
- Andrus Seeme
- Pipi-Liis Siemann
- Timo Suslov
- Margit Sutrop
- Andres Sutt
- Aivar Sõerd
- Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
- Urve Tiidus
- Kristo Enn Vaga
- Luisa Värk
Did not vote · 2- Eerik-Niiles Kross
- Vilja Toomast
Absent · 1- Mati Raidma
- Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 2In favour · 2
- Jaanus Karilaid
- Tõnis Mölder
- IsamaaMembers in total: 8
· ·
In favour · 6- Mart Maastik
- Andres Metsoja
- Urmas Reinsalu
- Helir-Valdor Seeder
- Priit Sibul
- Riina Solman
Did not vote · 1- Tõnis Lukas
Absent · 1- Aivar Kokk
- Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9Against · 9
- Anti Allas
- Raimond Kaljulaid
- Helmen Kütt
- Priit Lomp
- Tiit Maran
- Eduard Odinets
- Jevgeni Ossinovski
- Heljo Pikhof
- Reili Rand
Sources (Riigikogu documents) (9)
Official page of the bill on the Riigikogu website: proceedings and all documents.
- Introduction · Kaaskiri (pdf)
- Introduction · Eelnõu docx
- Introduction · Seletuskiri docx
- Introduction · Eelnõu pdf
- Introduction · Seletuskiri pdf
- Introduction · Seletuskirja lisa (märkused ja ettepanekud) pdf
- 1st reading · Eelnõu (docx)
- 1st reading · Seletuskiri (docx)
- 1st reading · Tagasivõtmise avaldus (pdf)