Decision of the Riigikogu "Making a Proposal to the Government of the Republic to Implement Effective Measures to Protect Minors from Exposure to Pornography" ↗
- Introduced:
- 3 April 2024
- Author:
- Conservative People's Party of Estonia
- Stage
- Rejected3 June 2024
The draft Riigikogu decision proposes that the Government take effective measures to protect minors from exposure to pornography. According to the explanatory memorandum, the current requirement is not met on websites without real age checks. The draft does not propose initiating any bill.
Key provisions
Proposal to the Government to protect minors from pornography
The Riigikogu proposes that the Government take effective measures to genuinely protect minors from exposure to pornography, as the current law requires. The decision names no specific measures.Enforcing the existing requirement for websites
According to the explanatory memorandum, current law requires pornographic works to be offered so that minors cannot view them, but many websites have no real age check. The initiators say the proposal is about enforcing existing law.Possible measures (examples in the memorandum)
The memorandum gives age verification by ID card, Mobiili-ID (mobile ID) or Smart-ID as an example. Another option it mentions is blocking such sites by default, with adults able to unblock them by applying to their internet service provider. The decision text does not include these, and the memorandum says other countries' experience should be analysed.
How the text changed during the proceedings
- The text of the draft did not change. The first-reading text only adds a note that the lead committee is the Cultural Affairs Committee (kultuurikomisjon).
Votes
Voting result
Official decision: Rejected
· · ·
By faction
- Estonia 200Members in total: 14
· ·
Against · 6- Juku-Kalle Raid
- Marek Reinaas
- Kalev Stoicescu
- Tarmo Tamm
- Igor Taro
- Toomas Uibo
Did not vote · 7- Lauri Hussar
- Züleyxa Izmailova
- Irja Lutsar
- Kadri Tali
- Peeter Tali
- Tanel Tein
- Hendrik Johannes Terras
Absent · 1- Liisa-Ly Pakosta
- Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6
·
Did not vote · 4- Vadim Belobrovtsev
- Andrei Korobeinik
- Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
- Lauri Laats
Absent · 2- Aleksei Jevgrafov
- Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
- Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16
·
In favour · 12- Arvo Aller
- Rain Epler
- Helle-Moonika Helme
- Mart Helme
- Martin Helme
- Kert Kingo
- Leo Kunnas
- Alar Laneman
- Siim Pohlak
- Evelin Poolamets
- Jaak Valge
- Varro Vooglaid
Did not vote · 4- Ants Frosch
- Rene Kokk
- Anti Poolamets
- Henn Põlluaas
- Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37
· ·
Against · 20- Annely Akkermann
- Anti Haugas
- Karmen Joller
- Mario Kadastik
- Mait Klaassen
- Eerik-Niiles Kross
- Urmas Kruuse
- Katrin Kuusemäe
- Kalle Laanet
- Eero Merilind
- Õnne Pillak
- Mati Raidma
- Valdo Randpere
- Pipi-Liis Siemann
- Timo Suslov
- Andres Sutt
- Aivar Sõerd
- Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
- Vilja Toomast
- Luisa Värk
Did not vote · 12- Siim Kallas
- Erkki Keldo
- Liina Kersna
- Meelis Kiili
- Ants Laaneots
- Hanah Lahe
- Maris Lauri
- Jürgen Ligi
- Maido Ruusmann
- Andrus Seeme
- Urve Tiidus
- Kristo Enn Vaga
Absent · 5- Yoko Alender
- Signe Kivi
- Toomas Kivimägi
- Marko Mihkelson
- Margit Sutrop
- Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 11
· · ·
In favour · 1- Kalle Grünthal
Against · 3- Jaak Aab
- Andre Hanimägi
- Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
Did not vote · 6- Enn Eesmaa
- Jaanus Karilaid
- Ester Karuse
- Tanel Kiik
- Jüri Ratas
- Kersti Sarapuu
Absent · 1- Tõnis Mölder
- IsamaaMembers in total: 8
· ·
In favour · 1- Priit Sibul
Did not vote · 6- Aivar Kokk
- Mart Maastik
- Andres Metsoja
- Urmas Reinsalu
- Helir-Valdor Seeder
- Riina Solman
Absent · 1- Tõnis Lukas
- Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9
· · ·
In favour · 2- Helmen Kütt
- Heljo Pikhof
Against · 5- Anti Allas
- Raimond Kaljulaid
- Madis Kallas
- Tiit Maran
- Reili Rand
Did not vote · 1- Eduard Odinets
Absent · 1- Priit Lomp