Kogulugu

Act Amending the Building Code, the Building Code and Planning Act Implementation Act and the State Assets Act ↗

Introduced:
14 November 2022
Author:
Government · coalition at introduction: Reform, Isamaa, SDE
Stage
Second reading

The draft adds a requirement to the Building Code (Ehitusseadustik) that the publicly visible part of a building and publicly exhibited monuments, sculptures and memorials must not incite hostility or support or justify an occupation regime or international crimes. According to the explanatory memorandum, the aim is to create a basis in building law for removing such objects. Administrative supervision goes to the Ministry of Justice, the list of special supervision measures grows, and a government commission is provided for. At second reading the deadline for bringing existing objects into line was extended from three to six months.

Key provisions

  1. New requirement for buildings and structures

    The publicly visible part of a building, and any publicly exhibited monument, sculpture, memorial or similar structure, must not incite hostility or support or justify an occupation regime, an act of aggression, genocide, a crime against humanity or a war crime. The requirement does not apply to property held by a museum.
  2. Deadline for bringing existing objects into line

    Buildings and structures built before the requirement enters into force must be brought into line within six months of its entry into force. The introduced text had three months.
  3. Ministry of Justice supervision of local authorities

    The Ministry of Justice (Justiitsministeerium) carries out administrative supervision of how a local authority follows the requirement. It may use direct coercion, and the police give official assistance. The general administrative supervision procedure (written proposal, protest) does not apply.
  4. More special measures for state supervision

    According to the memorandum, the special measures in sections 30, 31, 32, 49, 50, 51 and 52 of the Law Enforcement Act (korrakaitseseadus) could be used.
    Measures in sections 34, 44 and 53 are added (surveillance equipment, a ban on staying in a place, destroying a seized item or transferring it to state ownership).
  5. Grounds for demolition

    A law enforcement body decides on demolition mainly where non-compliance brings significant or heightened danger, or where unlawful construction has had a lasting, excessively burdensome effect on neighbours.
    Demolition is also possible where the non-compliance cannot be removed in any other way.
  6. Government commission

    Where needed, a government commission formed under the Government of the Republic Act determines whether a building or structure complies. It includes a representative of the National Heritage Board (Muinsuskaitseamet) and may include other experts.
  7. Monuments and heritage conservation areas

    When supervising a listed monument or a building in a heritage conservation area, the Heritage Conservation Act (muinsuskaitseseadus) is taken into account, and the National Heritage Board's opinion is sought where needed on whether a permit or notice is required.
  8. Manager of state property

    When a law enforcement body transfers property to state ownership, the manager is the ministry in whose area of government that body belongs. In cases tied to the new requirement involving local authorities and administrative supervision, the manager is the Ministry of Justice.

How the text changed during the proceedings

  • At second reading the economic affairs committee's proposal to extend the deadline from three to six months was accepted, since three months may not suffice, especially for a building in a heritage area. The initiator stayed neutral.
  • The proposal by the EKRE faction to simplify the wording and drop the words "inciting hostility" was not accepted (2 in favour, 5 against in committee).
  • According to the memorandum, the Riigikogu Chancellery's legal department and the Ministry of Justice gave differing assessments of constitutionality. The other changes were technical and linguistic.

Votes

Re-adoption unchanged

Official decision: Re-examination

· · ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 14

    ·

    Against · 13
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Irja Lutsar
    • Liisa-Ly Pakosta
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Kadri Tali
    • Peeter Tali
    • Tarmo Tamm
    • Igor Taro
    • Tanel Tein
    • Hendrik Johannes Terras
    • Toomas Uibo
    Did not vote · 1
    • Lauri Hussar
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 14

    · ·

    Against · 10
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
    • Tanel Kiik
    • Andrei Korobeinik
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
    • Lauri Laats
    • Jüri Ratas
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    Did not vote · 2
    • Jaak Aab
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
    Absent · 2
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    • Ester Karuse
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 17

    · · ·

    In favour · 3
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
    • Mart Helme
    • Rene Kokk
    Against · 8
    • Arvo Aller
    • Rain Epler
    • Ants Frosch
    • Kalle Grünthal
    • Leo Kunnas
    • Alar Laneman
    • Anti Poolamets
    • Evelin Poolamets
    Did not vote · 4
    • Martin Helme
    • Henn Põlluaas
    • Jaak Valge
    • Varro Vooglaid
    Absent · 2
    • Kert Kingo
    • Siim Pohlak
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    ·

    Against · 36
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Yoko Alender
    • Anti Haugas
    • Karmen Joller
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Siim Kallas
    • Erkki Keldo
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Signe Kivi
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Ants Laaneots
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Maris Lauri
    • Jürgen Ligi
    • Eero Merilind
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Pärtel-Peeter Pere
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
    • Timo Suslov
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Andres Sutt
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Vilja Toomast
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    • Luisa Värk
    Absent · 1
    • Mati Raidma
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 2

    In favour · 2
    • Jaanus Karilaid
    • Tõnis Mölder
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    · ·

    In favour · 4
    • Andres Metsoja
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    • Priit Sibul
    • Riina Solman
    Did not vote · 3
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Mart Maastik
    • Urmas Reinsalu
    Absent · 1
    • Aivar Kokk
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    Against · 9
    • Anti Allas
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
    • Helmen Kütt
    • Priit Lomp
    • Tiit Maran
    • Eduard Odinets
    • Jevgeni Ossinovski
    • Heljo Pikhof
    • Reili Rand
Sources (Riigikogu documents) (17)

Official page of the bill on the Riigikogu website: proceedings and all documents.