Kogulugu

Act Denouncing the Treaty between the Republic of Estonia and the Russian Federation on Legal Assistance and Legal Relations in Civil, Family and Criminal Matters ↗

Introduced:
22 January 2024
Author:
Government (Ministry of Justice) · coalition at introduction: Reform, Eesti 200, SDE
Stage
Adopted20 March 2024

The draft denounces (terminates) the 1993 agreement between Estonia and Russia on legal assistance and legal relations in civil, family and criminal matters. According to the explanatory memorandum, the reason is that Estonia lacks trust in the Russian legal system because of Russia's aggression against Ukraine. The memorandum says the agreement ends on 18.03.2025.

Key provisions

  1. Denouncing the legal assistance agreement

    The agreement signed in Moscow in 1993 is in force. It entered into force on 19.03.1995 and has been extended automatically for five-year periods, most recently in 2020.
    The agreement is denounced. According to the memorandum, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs sends Russia a note and the agreement ends on 18.03.2025.
  2. Civil and family matters: jurisdiction and applicable law

    According to the memorandum, the agreement took priority in the matters it covers. For example, claims for apartment association costs against an owner living in Russia fell under a Russian court.
    According to the memorandum, Hague conventions, EU regulations and national law apply instead, as with other third countries. It says such cost disputes would be heard by Estonian courts.
  3. Documents and recognition of court judgments

    According to the memorandum, documents for use in Russia needed no apostille under the agreement. Judgments were recognised under the agreement, which has no public-policy (avalik kord) ground for refusal.
    According to the memorandum, documents will need an apostille in future, and a court can also assess conflict with public policy when recognising a judgment. Service of documents and taking of evidence continue under the Hague conventions.
  4. Criminal matters and extradition

    According to the memorandum, the agreement categorically excludes extradition of an Estonian citizen to Russia. Prosecutor's offices communicated directly.
    According to the memorandum, extradition is no longer legally excluded, but Estonia has reserved the right to refuse if the citizen does not consent. Requests go through the central authority, the Ministry of Justice (Justiitsministeerium).

How the text changed during the proceedings

  • Between the first and second readings, Mart Maastik submitted one amendment proposal but withdrew it at the committee sitting.
  • The Legal Affairs Committee (õiguskomisjon) made no changes to the draft. The text stayed the same; only signatures and procedural notes changed.
  • The committee proposed by consensus to conclude the second reading and hold the final vote.

Votes

Voting result

Official decision: Adopted

· ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 14

    ·

    In favour · 13
    • Lauri Hussar
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Irja Lutsar
    • Liisa-Ly Pakosta
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Kadri Tali
    • Peeter Tali
    • Tarmo Tamm
    • Tanel Tein
    • Hendrik Johannes Terras
    • Toomas Uibo
    Did not vote · 1
    • Igor Taro
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6

    · ·

    In favour · 3
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
    Did not vote · 2
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
    • Andrei Korobeinik
    Absent · 1
    • Lauri Laats
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16

    · ·

    In favour · 3
    • Rene Kokk
    • Anti Poolamets
    • Henn Põlluaas
    Did not vote · 9
    • Arvo Aller
    • Rain Epler
    • Ants Frosch
    • Mart Helme
    • Martin Helme
    • Leo Kunnas
    • Alar Laneman
    • Siim Pohlak
    • Evelin Poolamets
    Absent · 4
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
    • Kert Kingo
    • Jaak Valge
    • Varro Vooglaid
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    · ·

    In favour · 26
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Anti Haugas
    • Karmen Joller
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Erkki Keldo
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Signe Kivi
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Ants Laaneots
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Jürgen Ligi
    • Eero Merilind
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Mati Raidma
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Andres Sutt
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    Did not vote · 5
    • Pärtel-Peeter Pere
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    • Luisa Värk
    Absent · 6
    • Yoko Alender
    • Siim Kallas
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Maris Lauri
    • Timo Suslov
    • Vilja Toomast
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 11

    · ·

    In favour · 4
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    • Jaanus Karilaid
    • Jüri Ratas
    Did not vote · 5
    • Kalle Grünthal
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Tanel Kiik
    • Tõnis Mölder
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    Absent · 2
    • Jaak Aab
    • Ester Karuse
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    ·

    Did not vote · 7
    • Aivar Kokk
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Mart Maastik
    • Andres Metsoja
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    • Priit Sibul
    • Riina Solman
    Absent · 1
    • Urmas Reinsalu
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    · ·

    In favour · 3
    • Anti Allas
    • Eduard Odinets
    • Reili Rand
    Did not vote · 5
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
    • Priit Lomp
    • Tiit Maran
    • Jevgeni Ossinovski
    • Heljo Pikhof
    Absent · 1
    • Helmen Kütt
Sources (Riigikogu documents) (13)

Official page of the bill on the Riigikogu website: proceedings and all documents.