Act Amending the Estonian Public Broadcasting Act ↗
- Introduced:
- 12 May 2023
- Author:
- Kalle Grünthal (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Alar Laneman (Conservative People's Party of Estonia)
- Stage
- Rejected21 February 2024
The draft amends the Estonian Public Broadcasting Act (Eesti Rahvusringhäälingu seadus). It adds political balance, a right of reply and internal control through responsible editors. According to the explanatory memorandum, it also aligns the rules on the council and management board with the Commercial Code (Äriseadustik).
Changes and additions
Number of programmes
According to the explanatory memorandum, the law requires at least two TV programmes and four round-the-clock radio programmes.The broadcaster (Rahvusringhääling) would have to produce at least one TV programme and one round-the-clock radio programme. The initiator says the broadcaster itself could decide the number.Political balance
If airtime is given to one party or political movement, the broadcaster must offer the same chance to another one in the same programme without undue delay. According to the memorandum, a similar rule was earlier in the Broadcasting Act (Ringhäälinguseadus) and was dropped.Right of reply
A person whose rights or reputation are harmed by incorrect facts would have the right to submit a reply. They must notify the broadcaster in writing within 20 days, and the broadcaster airs the reply within 20 days of a justified request.Morality and legality
The broadcaster would not air programmes that are immoral or contrary to the constitution or laws. Examples are programmes inciting hatred, containing pornography or unjustified violence.Responsible editors and end of the ethics adviser
The law has a post of ethics adviser and a section on it.The ethics adviser section is repealed. The broadcaster would appoint responsible editors who ensure compliance and monitor balance. According to the memorandum, the responsible editor takes over the ethics adviser's role.Election and recall of board members
According to the memorandum, only the chair of the management board can be recalled, and the grounds relate to serious breaches or management errors.The council (nõukogu) would elect and recall management board (juhatus) members and could recall a member regardless of the reason.Board member pay
Paragraph 27 subsections 3 and 4 were in force. The documents do not describe them in more detail.These subsections are repealed. The council could demand reduced pay if the broadcaster's economic situation worsens significantly.Duties of council and board
According to the memorandum, the law uses the concept of loyalty, and the council cannot supervise programmes.Council and board members must perform duties with the care of a diligent businessperson. The council would also supervise programmes.
How the text changed during the proceedings
- The only difference between the introduced and latest text is a note that the lead committee is the Cultural Affairs Committee.
Votes
Proposal to reject the bill
Official decision: Rejected
· · ·
By faction
- Estonia 200Members in total: 14
· ·
In favour · 9- Züleyxa Izmailova
- Irja Lutsar
- Juku-Kalle Raid
- Marek Reinaas
- Kalev Stoicescu
- Peeter Tali
- Tarmo Tamm
- Tanel Tein
- Hendrik Johannes Terras
Did not vote · 3- Liisa-Ly Pakosta
- Kadri Tali
- Toomas Uibo
Absent · 2- Lauri Hussar
- Igor Taro
- Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6Did not vote · 6
- Vadim Belobrovtsev
- Aleksei Jevgrafov
- Andrei Korobeinik
- Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
- Lauri Laats
- Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
- Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16
· ·
Against · 13- Arvo Aller
- Ants Frosch
- Helle-Moonika Helme
- Mart Helme
- Martin Helme
- Rene Kokk
- Leo Kunnas
- Alar Laneman
- Siim Pohlak
- Anti Poolamets
- Evelin Poolamets
- Henn Põlluaas
- Jaak Valge
Did not vote · 2- Rain Epler
- Varro Vooglaid
Absent · 1- Kert Kingo
- Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37
· ·
In favour · 24- Annely Akkermann
- Karmen Joller
- Mario Kadastik
- Siim Kallas
- Erkki Keldo
- Liina Kersna
- Toomas Kivimägi
- Mait Klaassen
- Urmas Kruuse
- Katrin Kuusemäe
- Ants Laaneots
- Hanah Lahe
- Maris Lauri
- Jürgen Ligi
- Eero Merilind
- Mati Raidma
- Valdo Randpere
- Maido Ruusmann
- Andrus Seeme
- Pipi-Liis Siemann
- Aivar Sõerd
- Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
- Urve Tiidus
- Vilja Toomast
Did not vote · 7- Anti Haugas
- Signe Kivi
- Pärtel-Peeter Pere
- Õnne Pillak
- Timo Suslov
- Andres Sutt
- Luisa Värk
Absent · 6- Yoko Alender
- Meelis Kiili
- Eerik-Niiles Kross
- Marko Mihkelson
- Margit Sutrop
- Kristo Enn Vaga
- Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 11
· · ·
In favour · 3- Andre Hanimägi
- Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
- Tanel Kiik
Against · 1- Kalle Grünthal
Did not vote · 6- Jaak Aab
- Enn Eesmaa
- Jaanus Karilaid
- Ester Karuse
- Tõnis Mölder
- Kersti Sarapuu
Absent · 1- Jüri Ratas
- IsamaaMembers in total: 8
·
Did not vote · 5- Tõnis Lukas
- Mart Maastik
- Helir-Valdor Seeder
- Priit Sibul
- Riina Solman
Absent · 3- Aivar Kokk
- Andres Metsoja
- Urmas Reinsalu
- Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9
· ·
In favour · 5- Raimond Kaljulaid
- Helmen Kütt
- Tiit Maran
- Eduard Odinets
- Jevgeni Ossinovski
Did not vote · 3- Anti Allas
- Priit Lomp
- Heljo Pikhof
Absent · 1- Reili Rand