Kogulugu

Act amending the Public Prosecutor's Office Act and the Courts Act ↗

Introduced:
12 May 2023
Author:
Kalle Grünthal (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Kert Kingo (Conservative People's Party of Estonia)
Stage
Rejected7 February 2024

The draft moves service supervision of the prosecutor's office from the Ministry of Justice to the Supreme Court (Riigikohus) and its disciplinary chamber. Prosecutors would fall under the disciplinary liability rules that apply to judges. According to the explanatory memorandum, the aim is to rule out use of criminal proceedings for political purposes and to speed them up.

Changes and additions

  1. Service supervision moved to the Supreme Court

    According to the explanatory memorandum, the Ministry of Justice (Justiitsministeerium) carried out service supervision over the prosecutor's office.
    The Supreme Court carries out service supervision over the prosecutor's office. It also covers surveillance planning, pre-trial criminal proceedings and representing the state prosecution in court.
  2. Disciplinary chamber as the supervisor

    The documents do not describe the earlier provision in more detail; per the memorandum, supervision lay with the Ministry of Justice.
    Supervision is carried out by the disciplinary chamber at the Supreme Court named in section 93 of the Courts Act (Kohtute seadus). The memorandum calls it the most competent and objective body.
  3. Starting disciplinary proceedings and rules

    The documents do not say what the earlier procedure for starting proceedings was.
    Supervision starts when signs of a disciplinary offence appear, and proceedings begin by drawing up a disciplinary charge. Chapters 8 to 11 of the Civil Service Act (Avaliku teenistuse seadus) apply.
  4. Who may start proceedings

    The documents do not describe the earlier group of persons.
    The President of the Supreme Court and the Chancellor of Justice (õiguskantsler) may start proceedings against all prosecutors. The president of a circuit court may do so against district prosecutors in their area.
  5. Initiator's right to collect evidence

    The initiator of proceedings may collect evidence needed to resolve the case and demand explanations.
  6. Courts Act disciplinary liability extended to prosecutors

    According to the memorandum, disciplinary liability under the Courts Act covered judges, not prosecutors.
    The rules on disciplinary penalties and offences apply to a prosecutor as well as a judge, and the chapter title changes. Chapters 8 to 11 of the Civil Service Act apply to prosecutors' proceedings.

Votes

Proposal to reject the bill

Official decision: Rejected

· · ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 14

    · ·

    In favour · 9
    • Lauri Hussar
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Kadri Tali
    • Peeter Tali
    • Igor Taro
    • Tanel Tein
    • Hendrik Johannes Terras
    • Toomas Uibo
    Did not vote · 2
    • Liisa-Ly Pakosta
    • Tarmo Tamm
    Absent · 3
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Irja Lutsar
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6

    ·

    In favour · 4
    • Andrei Korobeinik
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
    • Lauri Laats
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
    Did not vote · 2
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16

    · ·

    Against · 7
    • Ants Frosch
    • Mart Helme
    • Martin Helme
    • Kert Kingo
    • Rene Kokk
    • Leo Kunnas
    • Siim Pohlak
    Did not vote · 8
    • Arvo Aller
    • Rain Epler
    • Alar Laneman
    • Anti Poolamets
    • Evelin Poolamets
    • Henn Põlluaas
    • Jaak Valge
    • Varro Vooglaid
    Absent · 1
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    · ·

    In favour · 29
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Yoko Alender
    • Anti Haugas
    • Karmen Joller
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Siim Kallas
    • Erkki Keldo
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Signe Kivi
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Ants Laaneots
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Maris Lauri
    • Jürgen Ligi
    • Eero Merilind
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Mati Raidma
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Timo Suslov
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Andres Sutt
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Vilja Toomast
    Did not vote · 6
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Pärtel-Peeter Pere
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    • Luisa Värk
    Absent · 2
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 11

    · · ·

    In favour · 3
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    • Tanel Kiik
    Against · 1
    • Kalle Grünthal
    Did not vote · 5
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Jaanus Karilaid
    • Ester Karuse
    • Jüri Ratas
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    Absent · 2
    • Jaak Aab
    • Tõnis Mölder
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    ·

    Did not vote · 7
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Mart Maastik
    • Andres Metsoja
    • Urmas Reinsalu
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    • Priit Sibul
    • Riina Solman
    Absent · 1
    • Aivar Kokk
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    · ·

    In favour · 4
    • Anti Allas
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
    • Priit Lomp
    • Tiit Maran
    Did not vote · 2
    • Helmen Kütt
    • Jevgeni Ossinovski
    Absent · 3
    • Eduard Odinets
    • Heljo Pikhof
    • Reili Rand
Sources (Riigikogu documents) (6)

Official page of the bill on the Riigikogu website: proceedings and all documents.