Kogulugu

Riigikogu Resolution "Supporting the Introduction of Nuclear Energy in Estonia" ↗

Introduced:
8 May 2024
Author:
55 members (Estonian Reform Party 30, Non-affiliated members 5, Estonia 200 6, Isamaa 2, Conservative People's Party of Estonia 11, Estonian Centre Party 1)
Mario Kadastik (Estonian Reform Party), Eerik-Niiles Kross (Estonian Reform Party), Urve Tiidus (Estonian Reform Party), Andres Sutt (Estonian Reform Party), Eero Merilind (Estonian Reform Party), Õnne Pillak (Estonian Reform Party), Mait Klaassen (Estonian Reform Party), Valdo Randpere (Estonian Reform Party), Meelis Kiili (Estonian Reform Party), Siim Kallas (Estonian Reform Party), Maido Ruusmann (Estonian Reform Party), Kalle Laanet (Estonian Reform Party), Karmen Joller (Estonian Reform Party), Luisa Värk (Estonian Reform Party), Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski (Non-affiliated members), Maris Lauri (Estonian Reform Party), Toomas Uibo (Estonia 200), Kalev Stoicescu (Estonia 200), Igor Taro (Estonia 200), Signe Kivi (Estonian Reform Party), Riina Solman (Isamaa), Rain Epler (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Evelin Poolamets (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Arvo Aller (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Ants Frosch (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Andres Metsoja (Isamaa), Andrei Korobeinik (Estonian Centre Party), Marko Mihkelson (Estonian Reform Party), Margit Sutrop (Estonian Reform Party), Leo Kunnas (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Jürgen Ligi (Estonian Reform Party), Rene Kokk (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Alar Laneman (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Anti Haugas (Estonian Reform Party), Liisa-Ly Pakosta (Estonia 200), Mati Raidma (Estonian Reform Party), Timo Suslov (Estonian Reform Party), Jaak Valge (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Kersti Sarapuu (Non-affiliated members), Enn Eesmaa (Non-affiliated members), Hendrik Johannes Terras (Estonia 200), Juku-Kalle Raid (Estonia 200), Henn Põlluaas (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Katrin Kuusemäe (Estonian Reform Party), Anti Poolamets (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Toomas Kivimägi (Estonian Reform Party), Jaanus Karilaid (Non-affiliated members), Kristo Enn Vaga (Estonian Reform Party), Erkki Keldo (Estonian Reform Party), Martin Helme (Conservative People's Party of Estonia), Liina Kersna (Estonian Reform Party), Yoko Alender (Estonian Reform Party), Jüri Ratas (Non-affiliated members), Kristina Šmigun-Vähi (Estonian Reform Party), Andrus Seeme (Estonian Reform Party)
Stage
Adopted12 June 2024

This Riigikogu decision expresses support for preparing the introduction of nuclear energy in Estonia and for creating a suitable legal framework. According to the explanatory memorandum, it does not give the right to build a nuclear power plant but is the first step of the process. For the second reading, two points on the energy development plan and risk assessment were added, and the decision's legal basis was corrected.

Key provisions

  1. Support for preparing the introduction of nuclear energy

    The Riigikogu (Estonian parliament) supports preparing the introduction of nuclear energy and creating a suitable legal framework. According to the memorandum, this covers drafting a nuclear energy and safety act, creating a body to regulate safe use of nuclear energy, and developing competences.
  2. Addressing impacts in the energy development plan

    The Energy Sector Development Plan until 2035 (Energiamajanduse arengukava aastani 2035) is to address the impacts of introducing nuclear energy, in order to ensure security of energy supply during the transition to climate-neutral energy production.
  3. Thorough risk assessment

    When creating the legal framework, it must be ensured that risks related to national security, funding and form of ownership have been thoroughly assessed.
  4. Legal basis of the decision

    The decision was based on point 10 of § 65 of the Constitution (Eesti Vabariigi põhiseadus).
    The decision is based on points 1 and 16 of § 65 of the Constitution. According to the committee, the documents do not show that the Government had proposed that the Riigikogu take on financial obligations for the state.

How the text changed during the proceedings

  • Five amendment proposals were submitted for the second reading. The Environment Committee (keskkonnakomisjon) fully accepted its own proposals 4 and 5.
  • Mart Maastik's proposal (an action plan on energy supply security by 1 January 2025) and the Conservative People's Party faction's proposal (a nuclear plant with majority state ownership) were accepted in part through proposal 5.
  • A proposal by 19 members to make support conditional was accepted in substance through proposal 5.
  • The committee proposed holding the final vote.

Votes

Voting result

· · · ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 13

    · · ·

    In favour · 5
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Peeter Tali
    • Igor Taro
    • Toomas Uibo
    Against · 5
    • Irja Lutsar
    • Liisa-Ly Pakosta
    • Kadri Tali
    • Tarmo Tamm
    • Tanel Tein
    Did not vote · 1
    • Lauri Hussar
    Absent · 2
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Hendrik Johannes Terras
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6

    · ·

    In favour · 1
    • Andrei Korobeinik
    Against · 4
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
    • Lauri Laats
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
    Did not vote · 1
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16

    · ·

    In favour · 1
    • Leo Kunnas
    Did not vote · 12
    • Arvo Aller
    • Rain Epler
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
    • Mart Helme
    • Kert Kingo
    • Rene Kokk
    • Alar Laneman
    • Siim Pohlak
    • Anti Poolamets
    • Evelin Poolamets
    • Henn Põlluaas
    • Varro Vooglaid
    Absent · 3
    • Ants Frosch
    • Martin Helme
    • Jaak Valge
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    · ·

    In favour · 28
    • Yoko Alender
    • Anti Haugas
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Siim Kallas
    • Erkki Keldo
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Signe Kivi
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Kalle Laanet
    • Maris Lauri
    • Jürgen Ligi
    • Eero Merilind
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Mati Raidma
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
    • Timo Suslov
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Andres Sutt
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    Did not vote · 8
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Karmen Joller
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Ants Laaneots
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Vilja Toomast
    • Luisa Värk
    Absent · 1
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 12

    · · ·

    In favour · 3
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Jüri Ratas
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    Against · 6
    • Jaak Aab
    • Kalle Grünthal
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Ester Karuse
    • Tanel Kiik
    Abstained · 1
    • Tõnis Mölder
    Did not vote · 2
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    • Jaanus Karilaid
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    · · · ·

    In favour · 3
    • Aivar Kokk
    • Andres Metsoja
    • Riina Solman
    Against · 2
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Mart Maastik
    Abstained · 1
    • Priit Sibul
    Did not vote · 1
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    Absent · 1
    • Urmas Reinsalu
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    ·

    Against · 8
    • Anti Allas
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
    • Madis Kallas
    • Priit Lomp
    • Tiit Maran
    • Eduard Odinets
    • Heljo Pikhof
    • Reili Rand
    Did not vote · 1
    • Helmen Kütt

Termination of the II reading

· · ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 13

    · · ·

    In favour · 4
    • Irja Lutsar
    • Liisa-Ly Pakosta
    • Kadri Tali
    • Tarmo Tamm
    Against · 5
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Peeter Tali
    • Igor Taro
    • Toomas Uibo
    Did not vote · 2
    • Lauri Hussar
    • Tanel Tein
    Absent · 2
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Hendrik Johannes Terras
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6

    · ·

    In favour · 4
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
    • Lauri Laats
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
    Against · 1
    • Andrei Korobeinik
    Did not vote · 1
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16

    · ·

    Against · 1
    • Leo Kunnas
    Did not vote · 12
    • Arvo Aller
    • Rain Epler
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
    • Mart Helme
    • Kert Kingo
    • Rene Kokk
    • Alar Laneman
    • Siim Pohlak
    • Anti Poolamets
    • Evelin Poolamets
    • Henn Põlluaas
    • Varro Vooglaid
    Absent · 3
    • Ants Frosch
    • Martin Helme
    • Jaak Valge
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    · ·

    Against · 29
    • Yoko Alender
    • Anti Haugas
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Siim Kallas
    • Erkki Keldo
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Signe Kivi
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Kalle Laanet
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Maris Lauri
    • Jürgen Ligi
    • Eero Merilind
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Mati Raidma
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
    • Timo Suslov
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Andres Sutt
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    Did not vote · 7
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Karmen Joller
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Ants Laaneots
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Vilja Toomast
    • Luisa Värk
    Absent · 1
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 12

    · ·

    In favour · 7
    • Jaak Aab
    • Kalle Grünthal
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Ester Karuse
    • Tanel Kiik
    • Tõnis Mölder
    Against · 2
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    Did not vote · 3
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    • Jaanus Karilaid
    • Jüri Ratas
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    · · ·

    In favour · 3
    • Aivar Kokk
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Mart Maastik
    Against · 2
    • Andres Metsoja
    • Riina Solman
    Did not vote · 2
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    • Priit Sibul
    Absent · 1
    • Urmas Reinsalu
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    ·

    In favour · 8
    • Anti Allas
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
    • Madis Kallas
    • Priit Lomp
    • Tiit Maran
    • Eduard Odinets
    • Heljo Pikhof
    • Reili Rand
    Did not vote · 1
    • Helmen Kütt

Amendment proposal no. 3

· · ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 13

    · · ·

    In favour · 5
    • Irja Lutsar
    • Liisa-Ly Pakosta
    • Peeter Tali
    • Tarmo Tamm
    • Tanel Tein
    Against · 5
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Kadri Tali
    • Igor Taro
    • Toomas Uibo
    Did not vote · 1
    • Lauri Hussar
    Absent · 2
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Hendrik Johannes Terras
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6

    · ·

    In favour · 4
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
    • Lauri Laats
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
    Against · 1
    • Andrei Korobeinik
    Did not vote · 1
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16

    · ·

    Against · 2
    • Rain Epler
    • Leo Kunnas
    Did not vote · 11
    • Arvo Aller
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
    • Mart Helme
    • Kert Kingo
    • Rene Kokk
    • Alar Laneman
    • Siim Pohlak
    • Anti Poolamets
    • Evelin Poolamets
    • Henn Põlluaas
    • Varro Vooglaid
    Absent · 3
    • Ants Frosch
    • Martin Helme
    • Jaak Valge
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    · ·

    Against · 30
    • Yoko Alender
    • Anti Haugas
    • Karmen Joller
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Siim Kallas
    • Erkki Keldo
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Signe Kivi
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Kalle Laanet
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Maris Lauri
    • Jürgen Ligi
    • Eero Merilind
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Mati Raidma
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
    • Timo Suslov
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Andres Sutt
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    Did not vote · 6
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Ants Laaneots
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Vilja Toomast
    • Luisa Värk
    Absent · 1
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 12

    · ·

    In favour · 6
    • Jaak Aab
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Ester Karuse
    • Tanel Kiik
    • Tõnis Mölder
    Against · 1
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    Did not vote · 5
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Kalle Grünthal
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    • Jaanus Karilaid
    • Jüri Ratas
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    · · ·

    In favour · 4
    • Aivar Kokk
    • Mart Maastik
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    • Priit Sibul
    Against · 1
    • Andres Metsoja
    Did not vote · 2
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Riina Solman
    Absent · 1
    • Urmas Reinsalu
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    ·

    In favour · 8
    • Anti Allas
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
    • Madis Kallas
    • Priit Lomp
    • Tiit Maran
    • Eduard Odinets
    • Heljo Pikhof
    • Reili Rand
    Did not vote · 1
    • Helmen Kütt

Amendment proposal no. 2

· · ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 13

    · ·

    Against · 8
    • Irja Lutsar
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Kadri Tali
    • Peeter Tali
    • Tarmo Tamm
    • Igor Taro
    • Toomas Uibo
    Did not vote · 3
    • Lauri Hussar
    • Liisa-Ly Pakosta
    • Tanel Tein
    Absent · 2
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Hendrik Johannes Terras
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6

    Did not vote · 6
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
    • Andrei Korobeinik
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
    • Lauri Laats
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16

    · ·

    In favour · 10
    • Arvo Aller
    • Rain Epler
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
    • Mart Helme
    • Kert Kingo
    • Rene Kokk
    • Leo Kunnas
    • Anti Poolamets
    • Evelin Poolamets
    • Varro Vooglaid
    Did not vote · 3
    • Alar Laneman
    • Siim Pohlak
    • Henn Põlluaas
    Absent · 3
    • Ants Frosch
    • Martin Helme
    • Jaak Valge
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    · ·

    Against · 30
    • Yoko Alender
    • Anti Haugas
    • Karmen Joller
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Siim Kallas
    • Erkki Keldo
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Signe Kivi
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Kalle Laanet
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Maris Lauri
    • Jürgen Ligi
    • Eero Merilind
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Mati Raidma
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
    • Timo Suslov
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Andres Sutt
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    Did not vote · 6
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Ants Laaneots
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Vilja Toomast
    • Luisa Värk
    Absent · 1
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 12

    · ·

    In favour · 1
    • Kalle Grünthal
    Against · 2
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    Did not vote · 9
    • Jaak Aab
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    • Jaanus Karilaid
    • Ester Karuse
    • Tanel Kiik
    • Tõnis Mölder
    • Jüri Ratas
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    · ·

    Against · 1
    • Andres Metsoja
    Did not vote · 6
    • Aivar Kokk
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Mart Maastik
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    • Priit Sibul
    • Riina Solman
    Absent · 1
    • Urmas Reinsalu
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    Did not vote · 9
    • Anti Allas
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
    • Madis Kallas
    • Helmen Kütt
    • Priit Lomp
    • Tiit Maran
    • Eduard Odinets
    • Heljo Pikhof
    • Reili Rand

Amendment proposal no. 1

· · · ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 13

    · · · ·

    In favour · 2
    • Liisa-Ly Pakosta
    • Tanel Tein
    Against · 7
    • Irja Lutsar
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Kadri Tali
    • Tarmo Tamm
    • Igor Taro
    • Toomas Uibo
    Abstained · 1
    • Peeter Tali
    Did not vote · 1
    • Lauri Hussar
    Absent · 2
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Hendrik Johannes Terras
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6

    · ·

    In favour · 4
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
    • Lauri Laats
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
    Against · 1
    • Andrei Korobeinik
    Did not vote · 1
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16

    · ·

    Against · 1
    • Leo Kunnas
    Did not vote · 12
    • Arvo Aller
    • Rain Epler
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
    • Mart Helme
    • Kert Kingo
    • Rene Kokk
    • Alar Laneman
    • Siim Pohlak
    • Anti Poolamets
    • Evelin Poolamets
    • Henn Põlluaas
    • Varro Vooglaid
    Absent · 3
    • Ants Frosch
    • Martin Helme
    • Jaak Valge
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    · ·

    Against · 30
    • Yoko Alender
    • Anti Haugas
    • Karmen Joller
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Siim Kallas
    • Erkki Keldo
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Signe Kivi
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Kalle Laanet
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Maris Lauri
    • Jürgen Ligi
    • Eero Merilind
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Mati Raidma
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
    • Timo Suslov
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Andres Sutt
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    Did not vote · 6
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Ants Laaneots
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Vilja Toomast
    • Luisa Värk
    Absent · 1
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 12

    · ·

    In favour · 7
    • Jaak Aab
    • Kalle Grünthal
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Ester Karuse
    • Tanel Kiik
    • Tõnis Mölder
    Against · 2
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    Did not vote · 3
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    • Jaanus Karilaid
    • Jüri Ratas
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    · ·

    In favour · 6
    • Aivar Kokk
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Mart Maastik
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    • Priit Sibul
    • Riina Solman
    Against · 1
    • Andres Metsoja
    Absent · 1
    • Urmas Reinsalu
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    ·

    In favour · 8
    • Anti Allas
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
    • Madis Kallas
    • Priit Lomp
    • Tiit Maran
    • Eduard Odinets
    • Heljo Pikhof
    • Reili Rand
    Did not vote · 1
    • Helmen Kütt

Proposal to reject the bill

Official decision: First reading completed

· · ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 14

    · · ·

    In favour · 2
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Tarmo Tamm
    Against · 6
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Igor Taro
    • Hendrik Johannes Terras
    • Toomas Uibo
    Did not vote · 4
    • Lauri Hussar
    • Irja Lutsar
    • Kadri Tali
    • Tanel Tein
    Absent · 2
    • Liisa-Ly Pakosta
    • Peeter Tali
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 6

    ·

    In favour · 5
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
    • Lauri Laats
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
    Against · 1
    • Andrei Korobeinik
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 16

    · ·

    Against · 5
    • Rain Epler
    • Rene Kokk
    • Leo Kunnas
    • Henn Põlluaas
    • Jaak Valge
    Did not vote · 6
    • Arvo Aller
    • Mart Helme
    • Martin Helme
    • Siim Pohlak
    • Evelin Poolamets
    • Varro Vooglaid
    Absent · 5
    • Ants Frosch
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
    • Kert Kingo
    • Alar Laneman
    • Anti Poolamets
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    · ·

    Against · 28
    • Anti Haugas
    • Karmen Joller
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Siim Kallas
    • Erkki Keldo
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Signe Kivi
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Ants Laaneots
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Maris Lauri
    • Jürgen Ligi
    • Eero Merilind
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Mati Raidma
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Timo Suslov
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Andres Sutt
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    Did not vote · 6
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Kalle Laanet
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Vilja Toomast
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    Absent · 3
    • Yoko Alender
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
    • Luisa Värk
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 11

    · · ·

    In favour · 5
    • Jaak Aab
    • Kalle Grünthal
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Ester Karuse
    • Tanel Kiik
    Against · 4
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    • Jüri Ratas
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    Did not vote · 1
    • Jaanus Karilaid
    Absent · 1
    • Tõnis Mölder
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    · ·

    Against · 1
    • Urmas Reinsalu
    Did not vote · 6
    • Aivar Kokk
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Mart Maastik
    • Andres Metsoja
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    • Priit Sibul
    Absent · 1
    • Riina Solman
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    ·

    In favour · 7
    • Anti Allas
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
    • Madis Kallas
    • Helmen Kütt
    • Priit Lomp
    • Tiit Maran
    • Reili Rand
    Absent · 2
    • Eduard Odinets
    • Heljo Pikhof
Sources (Riigikogu documents) (10)

Official page of the bill on the Riigikogu website: proceedings and all documents.