Kogulugu

Act Amending the Courts Act and, in Connection Therewith, Amending Other Acts (Improving the Efficiency of Court Administration) ↗

Introduced:
21 April 2025
Author:
Government (Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs) · coalition at introduction: Reform, Eesti 200
Stage
Withdrawn

Draft 632 moves day-to-day administration of first- and second-instance courts from the Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs to the court system. It creates a Court Administration and Development Council (KHAN) and a Court Administration Service (KHT). The courts become a separate group in the state budget, and some rules for judges are eased. At second reading the entry-into-force dates were pushed back.

Changes and additions

  1. Court administration moves to the judiciary

    First- and second-instance courts are administered by the Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs together with the Council for Court Administration (kohtute haldamise nõukoda), an advisory and coordinating body.
    The Court Administration and Development Council (kohtute haldus- ja arendusnõukogu, KHAN) organises the administration of first- and second-instance courts. The ministry performs court administration tasks only where the law says so.
  2. Creation of KHAN and its composition

    KHAN has the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court (Riigikohus), two circuit court judges, three first-instance judges, two members of the Riigikogu (the Estonian parliament), a sworn advocate, the Chancellor of Justice (or a representative) and the justice and digital minister (or a representative). Judges are elected by the plenary of judges for three years. Court presidents may attend with the right to speak.
  3. KHAN competences

    KHAN directs and coordinates court administration, confirms development goals and the draft budget of the court group, sets court districts, courthouse locations and the number of judges, and appoints, dismisses and supervises court presidents. It also appoints the KHT director and issues the KHT statutes.
  4. New Court Administration Service (KHT)

    KHT (Kohtuhaldusteenistus) is a new court institution with a director appointed for five years (at most two terms in a row). Its tasks include HR, finance and property, support services, security, archives, communication and servicing KHAN.
  5. Court directors abolished; court presidents' role

    Court directors run court administration and approve structure and staff for non-judicial functions.
    The court director office (§ 125) is repealed. The court president approves the court's structure and staff, supervises court staff and administers the court together with KHT.
  6. Courts' budget in the state budget

    The ministry compiles the courts' budget and the courts are part of the ministry's area of government. The Council for Court Administration gives only an opinion.
    The first- and second-instance courts and KHT form a "court group" in the state budget. KHAN approves the draft budget and splits the funds, and its chair represents the courts in budget talks in the Riigikogu.
  7. Judges' part-time work and workload

    Part-time work for other reasons is limited to one year at a time, and the general assembly gives an opinion each time.
    The court president may allow part-time work for any other good reason, and the time limit (§ 371 lõige 2) is repealed. The president may also reduce workload for administrative or electoral commission duties.
  8. Judges' outside activities

    A judge may not sit on a company's management or supervisory board.
    A judge may take part in international organisations and do legislative drafting and creative work. A judge may sit on the board of a company in which he or she, or the joint property, holds the sole or a majority stake, if this does not harm the administration of justice.

How the text changed during the proceedings

  • Entry into force was postponed: the law now takes effect on 1 April 2026 (originally 1 January 2026). KHAN starts work on 1 November 2025 (originally 1 October 2025) and KHT on 1 April 2026. Court directors' powers last until 31 March 2026. The Supreme Court had considered the original timetable too fast.
  • A judge's membership of KHAN also ends if the judge's powers are suspended under § 584 lõige 3, for example on transfer to legal work in a state body or a university. A new clause makes KHAN, instead of the minister, formalise the transfer of a judge when a court president is appointed (KS § 57 lõige 11).
  • Amendments dropped the changes to the Code of Criminal Procedure, the Code of Misdemeanour Procedure and the Code of Civil Procedure, and § 11 (Government of the Republic Act). Reason given: the minister keeps the power to set requirements for access to procedural documents. Point 20 was also dropped because the replacement of "Justiitsministeerium" with "Justiits- ja Digiministeerium" had already been made.
  • No amendment proposals were submitted by the deadline of 27 May after the first reading on 13 May 2025. The Constitutional Committee submitted six amendments based on the Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs' proposals. It proposed ending the second reading and putting the draft on the full-house agenda for third reading on 18 June 2025.
  • Aaro Mõttus and Andra Laurand argued the draft removes too much of court administration from the legislature and executive, and that preparing the courts' budget without the government is constitutionally questionable. The Estonian Association of Judges wanted judges elected by judges to form a majority in KHAN and did not want Riigikogu members or the minister as members. It suggested the minister have only a right to attend and speak.
  • Supreme Court chair Villu Kõve said both administration models are constitutional. The Supreme Court's main concerns were the fast pace of implementation and securing next year's budget.

Votes

Termination of the II reading

· · ·

By faction
  • Estonia 200Members in total: 13

    · ·

    In favour · 7
    • Lauri Hussar
    • Ando Kiviberg
    • Juku-Kalle Raid
    • Stig Rästa
    • Kadri Tali
    • Tanel Tein
    • Toomas Uibo
    Did not vote · 5
    • Diana Ingerainen
    • Marek Reinaas
    • Kalev Stoicescu
    • Peeter Tali
    • Tarmo Tamm
    Absent · 1
    • Irja Lutsar
  • Estonian Centre PartyMembers in total: 7

    Did not vote · 7
    • Vladimir Arhipov
    • Vadim Belobrovtsev
    • Aleksei Jevgrafov
    • Andrei Korobeinik
    • Anastassia Kovalenko-Kõlvart
    • Lauri Laats
    • Aleksandr Tšaplõgin
  • Conservative People's Party of EstoniaMembers in total: 10

    ·

    Did not vote · 9
    • Arvo Aller
    • Helle-Moonika Helme
    • Mart Helme
    • Martin Helme
    • Rene Kokk
    • Siim Pohlak
    • Anti Poolamets
    • Evelin Poolamets
    • Varro Vooglaid
    Absent · 1
    • Rain Epler
  • Estonian Reform PartyMembers in total: 37

    · ·

    In favour · 30
    • Annely Akkermann
    • Yoko Alender
    • Anti Haugas
    • Jüri Jaanson
    • Toomas Järveoja
    • Mario Kadastik
    • Liina Kersna
    • Meelis Kiili
    • Mait Klaassen
    • Katrin Kuusemäe
    • Kalle Laanet
    • Hanah Lahe
    • Mihkel Lees
    • Eero Merilind
    • Marko Mihkelson
    • Õnne Pillak
    • Mati Raidma
    • Valdo Randpere
    • Signe Riisalo
    • Maido Ruusmann
    • Andrus Seeme
    • Pipi-Liis Siemann
    • Timo Suslov
    • Margit Sutrop
    • Aivar Sõerd
    • Kristina Šmigun-Vähi
    • Urve Tiidus
    • Madis Timpson
    • Mart Võrklaev
    • Luisa Värk
    Did not vote · 5
    • Toomas Kivimägi
    • Urmas Kruuse
    • Maris Lauri
    • Vilja Toomast
    • Kristo Enn Vaga
    Absent · 2
    • Signe Kivi
    • Eerik-Niiles Kross
  • Non-affiliated membersMembers in total: 17

    · ·

    In favour · 1
    • Maria Jufereva-Skuratovski
    Abstained · 1
    • Tanel Kiik
    Did not vote · 15
    • Jaak Aab
    • Enn Eesmaa
    • Peeter Ernits
    • Ants Frosch
    • Kalle Grünthal
    • Andre Hanimägi
    • Züleyxa Izmailova
    • Jaanus Karilaid
    • Ester Karuse
    • Leo Kunnas
    • Alar Laneman
    • Tõnis Mölder
    • Henn Põlluaas
    • Kersti Sarapuu
    • Jaak Valge
  • IsamaaMembers in total: 8

    · ·

    In favour · 2
    • Tõnis Lukas
    • Priit Sibul
    Did not vote · 5
    • Mart Maastik
    • Andres Metsoja
    • Urmas Reinsalu
    • Helir-Valdor Seeder
    • Riina Solman
    Absent · 1
    • Aivar Kokk
  • Social Democratic PartyMembers in total: 9

    · ·

    In favour · 1
    • Madis Kallas
    Did not vote · 7
    • Anti Allas
    • Helmen Kütt
    • Lauri Läänemets
    • Tiit Maran
    • Heljo Pikhof
    • Reili Rand
    • Riina Sikkut
    Absent · 1
    • Raimond Kaljulaid
Sources (Riigikogu documents) (12)

Official page of the bill on the Riigikogu website: proceedings and all documents.