Kogulugu

Pledges compared by theme

The 2023 pledges of the parties side by side: pick a theme in the table and the parties line up in columns below it. The numbers show how many pledges each party made on the theme. This sets wordings next to each other; it is not an assessment.

ThemeReformEesti 200EKREIsamaaSDEKeskParempoolsedRohelised
Taxes and budget925–283261321
Energy and climate3838–2219––19
Nature and agriculture3845–501373–56
Health252616474943–41
Education and science4034–38959467
Family and social protection212416337255320
State and law1954333444281836
Culture, language and sport2836–924779–38
Housing and regions3832–253933–6
Transport2224–22–––22
Defence and security402255411557416
Economy and labour24––34114109523
Foreign policy and migration1131631126–21

Education and science

ReformEesti 200EKREIsamaaSDEKeskParempoolsedRohelised

Estonian Centre Party

59 pledges

  • Double state funding for catering in educational institutions. We will ensure that all kindergarten children and schoolchildren receive healthy Estonian food funded by the state.

  • Guarantee every child a free kindergarten place. We will compensate local governments for the costs this entails.

  • Give every pupil of a general education school the opportunity to attend one free sports or hobby club at their own school.

  • We will raise teachers' average pay to 3000 euros in the coming years and increase other education workers' pay, keeping it competitive. Trade union representatives will take part in pay negotiations.

    Programme

    To raise the average salary of teachers to 3000 euros in the coming years, and, in cooperation between the state and local governments, to increase the salaries of other education workers, keeping them competitive compared with the Estonian average salary. We consider it important that trade union representatives are involved in salary negotiations for education workers.

  • To increase the relocation grant (lähetustoetus) for a beginning teacher and a support specialist to 25,000 euros.

  • To support aligning the salaries of the management of educational institutions with teachers' salaries and with competence and career models.

  • To increase, in cooperation between the state and local governments, the salaries of kindergarten teachers and support staff. To ensure the quality and availability of early childhood education across Estonia.

  • To value special education teachers, social pedagogues, school psychologists, youth work coordinators and speech therapists equally with teachers.

    Programme

    To value special education teachers, social pedagogues, school psychologists, youth work coordinators and speech therapists equally with teachers. To place more emphasis than before on training special education teachers and on improving the availability of their services in educational institutions.

  • To ensure, in cooperation between the state and local governments, a pay rise for hobby school teachers and coaches. We will link the salaries in hobby education and the salaries of coaches to the minimum salary rate of a teacher.

  • To ensure a good and safe educational environment in all local governments in Estonia. We will launch an investment programme to renovate and modernise our educational institutions across Estonia.

  • To support programmes that teach pupils habits of physical activity and healthy lifestyles. To this end, we will cooperate with the state, local governments, educational institutions, parents and the private sector.

  • To ensure that regional specifics are taken into account in school funding. Our goal is to keep schools and educational institutions open in smaller settlements in Estonia.

  • To raise teachers' competence in educational technology and to link curricula more closely with innovative solutions, both in independent work and in the classroom.

  • We will ensure enough teachers and support specialists and help schools get teaching materials. The Centre Party does not support a campaign-style move to Estonian-language education that puts teaching quality and teacher supply at risk.

    Programme

    To ensure a sufficient number of teachers and support specialists for implementing the national curriculum, and to support schools in preparing and procuring teaching materials. In the process of developing Estonian-language education, it must be ensured that the level of knowledge of general education school pupils and the quality of teaching do not decline. The Centre Party does not support a transition to Estonian-language education carried out as a political campaign, which endangers the quality of teaching and the provision of the necessary teachers in both Estonian- and Russian-language schools.

  • We will give students whose mother tongue is Russian partly Russian or bilingual teaching with deeper Estonian learning. We will support language immersion and integrated curricula in early and general education.

    Programme

    To ensure the quality of teaching, to offer pupils whose mother tongue is Russian partly Russian-language or bilingual instruction together with intensive Estonian language learning, in order to ensure that they acquire the necessary knowledge and have better opportunities for further study and for acquiring a profession. We support at the national level the use of different language immersion methodologies and integrated curricula in early childhood and general education.

  • To continue and expand the programme "Estonian-language teacher in an educational institution" (Eestikeelne õpetaja haridusasutuses), under which the state hires Estonian-speaking teachers for Russian-language kindergartens and schools.

  • To support the teaching of Estonian in schools abroad where Estonian children study. We will expand freely available digital learning materials in Estonian.

  • To amend the current conditions for completing basic school and upper secondary school (gymnasium), in order to ensure clearer and more uniform treatment of school leavers when continuing their studies.

  • To reduce the administrative workload and bureaucracy of general education school teachers by increasing the share of support staff in schools.

  • To improve cooperation between the health, social and education sectors in order to ensure the availability and quality of the support services children need, regardless of the child's place of residence and whether the child has special educational needs.

  • To develop the work of the network of student councils in all educational institutions.

  • To make kindergartens, basic schools, upper secondary schools (gymnasiums) and vocational schools safe and free of bullying. To apply more effective measures than before to prevent school violence and to help victims through professional counselling.

  • In cooperation with parents and teachers, to promote, within basic education, norms of behaviour on social media in order to protect the identity of every child and to prevent cyberbullying.

  • To expand technology, robotics and programming education in schools. We will provide every schoolchild with the equipment needed to study IT subjects.

  • To invest more than before in patriotic education in the education programme; national defence education in schools must be a compulsory part of the curriculum.

  • To support wider provision of religious studies as an elective subject.

  • To expand driving school theory and driving lessons in general education schools so that school leavers can obtain a category B driving licence with state support.

  • To increase the volume of road safety education in the first and second school stages.

  • To support including in the school curriculum topics related to everyday financial decisions, that is, financial literacy. We will develop investment education in general education schools.

  • To establish more separate schools than before for children with special educational needs. Pupils with special educational needs must have the opportunity to study in an educational institution that suits them.

  • To ensure better learning opportunities for students with special needs in vocational schools.

  • To develop a learner-centred education record (haridusajalugu) as an environment for a personal learning path and lifelong learning.

  • To make it easier for employers to offer childcare services to their employees; to this end, we will review the existing regulations.

  • To ensure that every basic school pupil gets at least 60 minutes of active physical activity within the school day's curriculum.

  • To ensure Estonian students the opportunity to obtain free, internationally competitive higher education. We consider it necessary to maintain and develop the pursuit of higher education in Estonian.

  • To raise state funding for higher education institutions to 1.5 percent of GDP in the coming years.

  • To keep state funding for research and development at the level of 1 percent of GDP.

  • To raise private sector funding for research and development to 2 percent of GDP. We support the necessary measures to encourage an increase in the share of private sector investment in research and development.

  • To strengthen cooperation between higher education institutions and the private sector so that research is more applicable to promoting the Estonian economy.

  • To involve more representatives of the Estonian Academy of Sciences in the state's strategic decision-making.

  • To ensure a competitive salary for university lecturers in order to retain current lecturers in higher education.

  • To enable universities to apply separate career ladders for lecturers and for researchers, so that people with better teaching skills can focus on teaching and researchers can focus more on research.

  • To link the state commissioning of places at Estonian universities more clearly to labour market needs and trends.

  • To ensure better integration of both Estonian and international students into the Estonian labour market. We will ensure state-supported organisation of traineeships in cooperation with the private sector.

  • To increase the social guarantees of students so that students can devote themselves fully to their studies.

    Programme

    To increase the social guarantees of students so that students can devote themselves fully to their studies. To change the study loan repayment system so that the state can cover the study loan in full, on condition that the person works in the public sector in the field they studied for at least three years.

  • To restore the system under which, when a student becomes a parent during their studies, one parent can apply for the state to write off part of the study loan.

  • To ensure better study opportunities for students with special needs in higher education institutions.

  • To support lifelong learning and the activities of folk universities (rahvaülikool) in adult education.

  • To provide state support to regional colleges in order to improve the availability of higher education across Estonia.

  • To support the continuation and development of university programmes for older people in local governments (for example the University of the Third Age, etc.).

  • Ensure that young people have the opportunity to obtain a housing loan to purchase their own home with a state guarantee and without a mandatory down payment.

  • Pay special attention to young people who go abroad to study, so that their connection with their homeland is preserved. We will help integrate them into Estonia's network of international relations.

  • Provide every pupil of a general education school with one free sports or hobby club at their school, and offer children from low-income families the opportunity to attend summer camps free of charge.

  • Support young people's awareness of the need for physical activity and develop the availability of recreational physical activity in every region.

  • Strengthen the role of youth councils and youth associations in society through broader inclusion.

  • Support the expansion of the student work brigade (õpilasmalev) activities in order to offer more young people work opportunities. We will involve young people in volunteer work.

  • Value all national cultures living here. We will continue to support the cultural societies and Sunday schools of national minorities.

  • Ensure free Estonian language learning for everyone who wishes it.

  • Develop a separate training system that provides Estonian language courses tailored to different professions and fields of activity.

Isamaa

38 pledges

  • will increase the funding of higher education institutions, with an emphasis on Estonian-language curricula, and will help foreign lecturers who stay in Estonia for a long time to learn Estonian, so that they can take part in administrative work and also teach on Estonian-language curricula,

  • will organise the funding of higher education institutions on the basis of the aim of promoting the development of the Estonian scientific language:

  • at bachelor's and master's level, Estonian-language instruction must be ensured; if a curriculum is in English, there must also be an option to study a similar curriculum in Estonian,

  • universities must offer foreign students at all levels instruction in the Estonian language and culture,

  • at least 50% of doctoral graduates must have a command of Estonian at level B2,

  • doctoral theses written in a foreign language must be accompanied by a comprehensive summary in Estonian, in order to promote the development of the Estonian scientific language.

  • will raise the minimum teacher salary rate to 125% of the Estonian average salary,

  • will allocate funds to raise the salaries of teachers in early childhood education and hobby schools (huvikool), paying a state salary subsidy for this purpose, similar to the pay system for coaches and leaders of singing and dance groups,

  • will value the leading role of the teacher in preserving the Estonian nation, language and culture throughout the ages, and will protect the teacher in this work,

  • in order to popularise the teaching profession, will continue paying a stipend in pedagogical fields of study at universities, will create a counselling system and will support initiatives that provide support to beginning teachers,

  • will restore the teacher career model, in which raising qualifications leads to a higher salary,

  • will reduce the teacher's workload,

  • will increase the salary supplement of the class teacher,

  • will continue to support the principle that the salary of a kindergarten teacher must be at least 90% of the minimum salary rate of a school teacher if they hold a bachelor's degree, and 100% if they hold a master's degree.

  • will ensure the availability of higher education in Estonian,

  • in order to maintain the vitality of Estonian culture and to create added value in the economy, will ensure state funding of research and development at 1% of GDP,

  • will make it possible to raise the salary rate of a university professor to 4 times the Estonian average,

  • of an associate professor to 3 times, and of a lecturer with a doctorate to 2 times; to implement this, will introduce the necessary changes to the basis of funding of higher education institutions,

  • will raise the ceiling of the study loan, extend the repayment period and ensure partial forgiveness of the study loan when a person becomes a parent,

  • will seek ways to motivate people who have obtained higher education in Estonia to use their education in Estonia.

  • will bring vocational education curricula and the school network into line with labour market needs,

  • will involve employers in cooperation with the vocational and higher education network, will create an effective system of workplace-based vocational training, and will continue and expand apprenticeship training and other forms of work placement, with the aim of giving young people the skills…

    Programme

    will involve employers in cooperation with the vocational and higher education network, will create an effective system of workplace-based vocational training, and will continue and expand apprenticeship training and other forms of work placement, with the aim of giving young people the skills needed for working life,

  • will increase students' freedom of choice by removing barriers and so-called dead ends in a young person's movement through the education system, and will offer joint curricula of vocational schools and upper secondary schools (gymnasiums),

  • will ensure that a graduate of a vocational education institution has equal opportunities with a graduate of an upper secondary school (gymnasium) to continue their studies.

  • will shape the curricula of all levels of education in accordance with the development needs of Estonian society and students, including

  • will introduce compulsory national defence instruction (riigikaitseõpetus) in upper secondary schools (gymnasiums) and vocational schools, in order to give young people the knowledge needed to act in a crisis situation,

    Ministry of Finance's opinion: The number of compulsory courses is fixed in the Basic Schools and Upper Secondary Schools Act. The proposal therefore requires amending the Basic Schools and Upper Secondary Schools Act.

  • will pay special attention to raising awareness of the Estonian nation, language and culture, religions and spiritual heritage, the creation and preservation of a healthy family, and financial literacy,

  • will increase schools' decision-making power in offering a programme of elective subjects based on the school's specific character,

  • will integrate joint curricula of general and vocational education in order to provide additional opportunities for students of both upper secondary schools (gymnasiums) and vocational education institutions,

  • will develop a work habit in children and young people in cooperation with schools in the field of work education, extracurricular activity organisers and entrepreneurs;

    Programme

    will develop a work habit in children and young people in cooperation with schools in the field of work education, extracurricular activity organisers and entrepreneurs; will encourage offering work to children during the summer period, seeking ways to involve farmers and to link children's camps with rural enterprise,

  • will ensure that state, municipal and private schools have equal financial opportunities to provide education, in order to support the diversity of the education system,

  • will oppose school bullying, will support programmes for making schools bullying-free and will look after students' mental health,

  • will develop and implement a system for the certification of school principals, in order to ensure a high standard of educational institutions,

  • will provide diverse hobby education (huviharidus).

  • in cooperation with higher education institutions, will develop a system of micro-credentials in order to expand adults' opportunities for self-improvement,

  • in cooperation with the Unemployment Insurance Fund (töötukassa) and employers, will expand opportunities for career change and practical training, in order to increase flexibility in the labour market,

  • will create a motivation package for lifelong vocational learning and retraining of working people, including raising the digital and smart-device awareness of older people and developing opportunities for people with special needs to participate in working life.

  • 4. We will switch kindergartens, schools and military institutions to organic catering, giving preference to local raw materials.

Estonian Greens (Eestimaa Rohelised)

67 pledges · Not in the Riigikogu

  • We will support environmental education programmes and environmental training for kindergarten teachers, so that children learn to live in balance with nature.

    Programme

    Environmental education as part of early childhood education must give the child a lifelong sense of living in balance with nature. In kindergarten, children must learn to cherish and value life, protect living beings and learn empathy across species. Caring for nature as an inner need begins in childhood. We support environmental education programmes and environmental education training for kindergarten teachers.

  • We will help local governments set up free playrooms and expand opportunities for outdoor activities, so that there are places where children raised at home can play with each other. This will develop children's social skills and allow stay-at-home parents to socialise with each other.

  • We consider it necessary for speech therapists, psychologists, special education teachers and social workers to cooperate more closely with kindergartens. Greater funding for their work is also important.

  • We will improve the connection of theoretical learning to everyday life. We support interdisciplinary teaching in school and the synchronised teaching of subjects in relation to one another.

  • We support the restoration and expansion of school gardens.

  • We believe school must develop the skills to find and critically assess information, analyse, be creative, and grow socially. Philosophising with children helps with this.

    Programme

    We believe that school must develop the ability to find necessary information and assess it critically, analytical and synthesis skills, and the creativity to apply what has been learned in everyday life and in making sense of the world. Philosophising with children helps with this. School must develop the child socially and give the ability to listen to others and act together.

  • We will equip schools with modern tools for manual and physical activity and for practical learning in technology, biology, physics and chemistry lessons.

  • We will create equal opportunities for acquiring education at all levels. We favour creating a comprehensive environment of video lectures for all general education subjects. We are against concentrating basic and secondary education in centres.

  • Small primary schools must be preserved and, where there are enough pupils, restored, so that pupils can attend school close to where they live, which is crucial for the development of rural areas and for young people to move to and stay in the countryside.

  • We favour greater integration of school subjects, so that the child develops as connected and comprehensive a worldview as possible.

  • We will weave natural values, the principles of environmental protection and respect for nature into every curriculum, level of education, school subject and educational institution.

  • We will increase the share of elective subjects in upper secondary school (gümnaasium) and the possibility of choosing an elective subject at another upper secondary school, vocational school or higher education institution.

  • We will increase the share of elective subjects in basic school (põhikool), giving schools the opportunity to find their own way to achieve learning outcomes and pupils the opportunity to study according to individual curricula.

  • We will encourage the teaching of the local language, dialect and culture in general education schools, as well as partial instruction in the local language (for example, in Seto or Võro).

  • We will introduce meditation and yoga in physical education lessons and during breaks. They will be voluntary for schools.

  • We will enable all pupils to study religious studies as an elective subject, giving an overview of the world's religions and the great diversity of religious beliefs, including the creation stories of indigenous peoples.

  • We support natural science and inventor clubs for children and young people across the country.

  • We support establishing and expanding Estonian-language learning opportunities in schools abroad where the Estonian community is sufficiently large. We support creating a global Estonian-language online school for those who have to live away from Estonia.

  • We will expand e-learning opportunities for pupils for whom it is better suited, who live far from school buildings, and in schools that have no teacher of the subject concerned.

  • We will reduce the compulsory study load and teachers' workload. Instead we will create options for voluntary extra learning, and the number of school days a year stays the same.

    Programme

    We will reduce the compulsory study load, which will also reduce teachers' workload. Instead, we will create opportunities to voluntarily study additional general subjects, prepare for state exams and olympiads, study at a science school or university, and acquire practical skills at a hobby school, vocational school or workplace, as a result of which the number of school days per year will remain the same.

  • We will make the fight against school bullying a priority and develop appropriate measures to make school a safe learning environment. When compiling school rankings, we consider it important to also take a school bullying index into account.

  • We will reform maritime education, make its structure more Western, and reduce the fragmentation and duplication of curricula.

  • We will create the possibility for pupils of general education schools to take academic leave, in order to reduce school dropout.

  • In funding, we will also take giftedness into account as an additional need. The teacher of a gifted child has an important role in understanding, developing and recognising the child's abilities.

  • We will give every child and young person the opportunity to take part free of charge in the activities of at least one hobby school or club.

  • We will promote the spread of full-day schools.

  • We will integrate schools, libraries and community centres into a network of hobby education / non-formal education.

  • We will focus on health-promoting physical culture and on developing an everyday culture of physical activity, so that exercise in the fresh air and in nature is available to our children.

  • We will develop a vocational training order that takes into account both current and near-future needs, involving all relevant parties. We will improve the learning environment and practical training base of vocational schools.

  • We will give parties interested in employees flexible opportunities to take part directly in training, to provide apprenticeships and workplace-based learning, to offer internship places, and to support training financially without taxation.

  • We will give students of general education schools the opportunity to take a certain number of hours of training at a vocational school, so that on graduating from school they can receive a certificate for a course or training. We will involve vocational schools in adult lifelong learning.

  • The curricula of vocational schools should be developed on a scientific basis by the higher education institutions teaching the relevant speciality, in cooperation with entrepreneurs; ideally, vocational schools should be able to choose between different curricula.

  • To enable students of vocational schools to take part in projects in their field at higher education institutions.

  • We will ensure opportunities for obtaining vocational education for everyone who wishes it.

  • We welcome the 15% annual increase in higher education funding provided for in the 2022 government coalition agreement and will see to it that it continues, in order to compensate for the severe underfunding in previous years.

  • We support the development of Estonian-language bachelor's degree programmes in parallel with English-language ones.

  • We support adding the topics of nature conservation, ecology and sustainability to all curricula where they are not yet included.

  • We support interdisciplinary cooperation across faculties.

  • We consider it necessary to recognise lecturers and researchers separately and to have different attestation criteria.

    Programme

    We consider it necessary to recognise lecturers and researchers separately and to have different attestation criteria. Depending on the field and the level of study, teaching skill may be more important for a lecturer than articles in internationally distributed journals and the ability to apply for project funding.

  • We will allow working students to study part-time free of charge, thereby encouraging them to find work in their field or traineeships. Companies where students will later start working must be involved in drawing up vocational and higher education curricula.

  • We will provide free higher education based on credit points (ainepunkt) instead of the current time-based completion of the curriculum, to give students the opportunity to choose their own pace of study and to combine study with work.

  • The student loan must be a measure to ensure social justice, not a banking business project. When setting the interest rate of the student loan, we will take into account the actual rise in the cost of living and we will extend the repayment period of the student loan.

    Programme

    The student loan must be a measure to ensure social justice, not a banking business project. When setting the interest rate of the student loan, we will take into account the actual rise in the cost of living and we will extend the repayment period of the student loan. We will write off part of the student loan upon the birth of a child.

  • We will focus on integrating foreign students, lecturers and researchers into university life and Estonian society. Our priority is that as many international degree students as possible stay and work in Estonia.

    Programme

    We will pay attention to integrating foreign students, lecturers and researchers into university life and Estonian society, taking into account their different cultural backgrounds and incomplete command of Estonian. Our priority is that as many international graduate students as possible stay in Estonia and enter the local labour market.

  • We will establish a base salary for university lecturers.

  • We will ensure that free higher education in Estonian continues, so that every person in Estonia, regardless of their social and economic position, has the opportunity to go as far in education as they wish in the national language.

  • We support the availability of support specialists for people with special needs for children, learners, parents and teachers; we will create financial incentives and support mechanisms for providing the service and ensuring its effectiveness.

  • We will improve vocational education opportunities for people with additional needs.

  • We will make learning lifelong and life-centred. We will ensure that people have the opportunity to upgrade their skills and retrain, taking into account changes in technology and society and their role in society.

  • We will make adult education a natural part of the education system.

  • We will provide adults with a student loan for study and retraining.

  • We will allow adult learners to obtain basic and upper secondary education more flexibly, for example as external students and by studying from video lectures.

  • We support joint learning and training of a child and a parent, for example the opportunity to take part, for a moderate fee, in courses offered by teachers; we support intergenerational joint learning, in which different generations learn from each other.

  • We will develop joint education programmes for people with different mother tongues in order to promote integration.

  • We will promote education programmes that support systems thinking.

  • We support education projects that raise public awareness and are aimed at taking responsibility.

  • We will improve the training and methods of teachers and adult educators, so that teachers give students tasks suited to them and help them grow into independent learners.

    Programme

    We will improve the training and methodology of pedagogues and andragogues: an effective teacher, together with other teachers, shows initiative and adapts their teaching methods, offering the student learning tasks that take individuality into account, involves students in setting goals and supports their development into autonomous, self-regulated learners.

  • A novice teacher is supported by a mentor and colleagues, and their workload is smaller at the start.

  • We support teachers' professional self-development and will create opportunities for study leave.

  • Within the next 10 years we will raise research funding to three percent of GDP, half of which will be state research funding.

  • We support a basic salary for academic researchers that is independent of projects. The quality of research must be ensured by attestation, not by competition.

  • We will oblige state institutions and companies to commission studies and expert opinions from scientists on nationally important issues, and we will take their results into account in the decision-making process.

  • We will remove excess bureaucracy in buying equipment for research, such as the public procurement requirement, so that researchers can use project money economically.

    Programme

    We will remove excessive bureaucracy in acquiring the means necessary for research, such as the public procurement obligation, so that scientists can handle project funds as economically as possible. A leading scientist essentially acts as an entrepreneur on the project market: to obtain funding for the next project, resources must be used economically. Therefore there is no need for a procurement system, one of whose aims is to ensure economical use of resources.

  • We support the growth in the number and the employment of specialists and scientists with a doctoral degree in Estonia. To this end, we will design targeted scholarships and provide postdoctoral positions in Estonia for those who have defended a doctorate both here and elsewhere.

  • We will increase the state funding pool so Estonian researchers can take full part in foreign projects. We will also give money for preparing large European research grant applications and for cooperation with foreign institutions.

    Programme

    To increase the visibility of Estonian science in the world, we will increase the state funding pool for full participation in foreign projects. We will provide researchers with financial support for preparing applications for large European research grants, for cooperation to this end with foreign research institutions and for participation in research cooperation networks.

  • We will introduce tax incentives for private investment in science. We will exempt research scholarships paid by companies from personal taxes on the same basis as state scholarships.

  • Under the leadership of the Greens, Estonia will become one of the world's centres for the development and application of artificial intelligence.

  • We recognise the Võro and Seto languages in Estonia as indigenous languages in their own right and will end their treatment as a dialect or a regional variant.

Parempoolsed (“The Right-wingers”)

4 pledges · Not in the Riigikogu

  • To boost innovation, we will ambitiously raise the quality of teaching and research at Estonian universities so that one Estonian university ranks among the top one hundred in the world.

  • To raise the quality of higher education, we will ensure the necessary state funding and give universities greater opportunities to attract private funds.

  • In planning the school network, we start from the principle that the sole purpose of a school is to give our children the best education in the world.

  • To bring the best school education in Estonian to every corner of Estonia, we will create modern learning platforms and make the teaching profession attractive.

Themes are assigned automatically: a pledge by the heading of its section in the party's programme (or its text), a bill by its Riigikogu tags; one bill can be in several themes. This is background, not a conclusion about whether pledges were kept. The rules: About.